8 Types of Narcissistic Family Scapegoat

In simple terms, a scapegoat is someone unfairly targeted with projected shame, rage, and blame by another person or group. In the emotionally illiterate and volatile narcissistic family, it is common for one child to be singled out for ongoing scapegoating. This child is made to carry the narcissistic parents‘ negative projections (feelings, thoughts, and behavior in themselves they wish to disown), while also frequently being burdened with adult responsibilities in the family.

8 Types/Dimensions of Family Scapegoat

Why a particular child becomes targeted as the family scapegoat is influenced by a mix of factors such as gender, birth order, and personality traits. Scapegoated children may try many strategies to manage their painful role in the dysfunctional family system and win whatever validation they can get from their parents. Because of the ongoing devaluation and exploitation they are subjected to, scapegoats struggle to develop healthy self-esteem and boundaries, and they often make great personal sacrifices in an effort to earn the highly conditional approval that passes for love in narcissistic homes.

A scapegoated child may adopt one or multiple forms of the coping patterns listed below. For example, a child with a rebellious response may also be truth telling and protective, or a child who does problem solving may also be perfectionist and/or caretaking. More than one child in a family may be scapegoated if, for example, a sibling leaves home or other circumstances change.

1. Caretaker

Scapegoated children may provide emotional and/or physical caretaking of one or more of their parents/stepparents, functioning as a stand-in best friend, spouse, therapist, or nurse. They may be given household responsibilities such as cleaning, cooking, and caring for siblings, while also being targeted with anger and blame for the family’s woes. Often intuitive and empathetic, caretaker scapegoats can become powerful healers as adults. But if they continue to prioritize the needs of others over their own they are likely to experience anxiety, poor self-care, resentment, and burnout.

2. Problem-Solver

The problem-solver child steps up to handle things for the family. This child may take over in crisis situations, advise or make decisions for the parents, manage aspects of the household, and perhaps earn money for the family. Problem-solver scapegoats may win short-term approval and/or a reprieve from criticism and drama by fixing problems, but, like caretakers, they are being exploited for the service they provide at the expense of their needs and healthy development. As adults, they often show capable leadership but struggle with feeling hypervigilant to potential threats, over-responsible for the well-being of others, and uncomfortable asking for help.

3. Protector

Children in the protector role step in to defend a parent and/or younger sibling(s) from the dominant narcissist’s verbal and/or physical abuse. Such children may be driven to try to protect family members because of their own experience with being scapegoated, or they may become the family scapegoat as a result of standing up to the abuse. As adults, children who have confronted the aggression of abusers may become fierce and compassionate advocates for justice and the underprivileged. But they often struggle to recognize their own limits, vulnerability, and need for support.

4. Truth-Teller

Children who recognize and attempt to talk about the family dysfunction (e.g., inequities, rage, neglect, boundary violations) are trying to resolve the cognitive dissonance between their experience of reality and the denials and distortions pushed by their gaslighting parent(s). Like protectors, truth-telling children in narcissistic homes may be motivated to question the family system because they are scapegoated, or they may be targeted with scapegoating because their awareness is viewed as a threat. Perceptive and often wise or even visionary, truth-tellers can be powerful social analysts, writers, fighters for justice, and whistleblowers. But seeing more than others do can also set them up for frustration, loneliness, and resentment from others who prefer to deny difficult truths.

5. Perfectionist/Achiever

Scapegoated children may attempt to win approval, avoid criticism, and disprove negative narratives about themselves through perfectionist patterns and high achievement. Such efforts can earn them passing validation or reprieves from negative attention, but typically very little the family scapegoat does is acknowledged or valued. Driven and often intelligent and talented, perfectionists/achievers may develop great capabilities, but they tend to struggle with a harsh inner critic, a need for control, and unrealistic standards for themselves and others.

6. Rebel

Family scapegoats may react to the unfairness of their role by adopting a pattern of ongoing rebellion against forms of control and authority in general. Unable to get their needs met or process their frustration in healthy ways, they compensate for feelings of powerlessness through defiant behavior. Like family truth-tellers, rebels are often driven by a desire for justice and can be powerful fighters for a cause. But they can be aimless and self-sabotaging unless they recognize the source of their anger and find constructive ways to focus their energy.

7. Collapsed

Some scapegoated children experience such harsh neglect and abuse with few sources of support to build resiliency that they fail to thrive and become mentally unstable, chronically ill, chronically unemployed, disabled, suicidal, institutionalized, homeless, consumed by addiction, and/or incarcerated. As adults, they may experience a trajectory of low functioning, repeating crisis, or collapse that ends tragically in early death by illness, addiction, suicide, or violence. Kids who are “different” in some way, such as queer or neuro-atypical, are often targets of extreme scapegoating both within their family and society at large.

8. Covert Narcissist

Of the child roles in the narcissistic family, the entitled and enmeshed golden child is probably most likely to develop a narcissistic personality. However, being scapegoated can also lead to narcissism, particularly the covert form. Scapegoated children who become narcissistic have typically been trained to submit to the dominance of a more overtly narcissistic parent (and perhaps golden child sibling) and as a result learn to cloak their rage, superiority, and desire for control into passive aggression. In adulthood, scapegoated covert narcissists often identify as victims and may use that to garner sympathy while also subjecting others to the neglect and abuse they experienced growing up.

The Path to Healing for the Family Scapegoat

The experience of the family scapegoat can be extremely painful and damaging to self-esteem and identity development. But there are redemptive aspects of the role. Scapegoats are often empathetic, independent-minded, capable, and committed to justice. And their outsider status can work to their advantage by pushing them to question the family system and establish independence from it, which are necessary steps to breaking the generational cycle of trauma and working on recovery.

The path to healing for scapegoats is establishing safety and stability, building self-esteem and healthy boundaries, and replacing conditioned and compulsive coping patterns with self-awareness, self-compassion, and reciprocal relationships.

Listen to Julie’s audio course “Understanding Narcissism” for half the cost of a coaching session.

Julie L. Hall is the author of The Narcissist in Your Life: Recognizing the Patterns and Learning to Break Free from Hachette Books. 

Need support? Julie provides specialized narcissistic trauma recovery coaching to clients around the world.

Related Articles by Julie L. Hall

• 7 Lies We Like to Tell Ourselves About Narcissism
• The Ugly Truth About Narcissistic Grandparents
• The Narcissist’s Antagonistic Attachment: Subjugation, Competition, and Parasitism
• Dear Therapist: You Missed My Husband’s Narcissism and It Devastated My Family
• Social and Performance Anxiety in Children of Narcissists
• Your Narcissistic Mother Hates Your Body and Here’s Why
• Are You Being Bullied By Narcissistic Monologuing?
• 5 Things Children of Narcissists Wish Everyone Would Stop Saying
• The Hidden Trauma of Neglect in the Narcissistic Family
• Why Narcissists Will Never Love You and It’s Dangerous to Love Them
• How Narcissists Torture Others and Believe They’re Right to Do It
• The Narcissist’s Disrespect, Envy, and Contempt
• Why Narcissists Play the Shame Game
• How and Why Narcissists Are Highly Skilled Abusers
• It’s You and Me Baby: Narcissist Head Games
• 7 Things a Narcissist Will Never Do
• The Narcissist as Human Parasite: Are You a Host?
• How to Protect Your Child from Your Narcissist Spouse
• Understanding Narcissistic Rage and Why It Is Not Your Fault
• Seven Sure Ways to Spot a Narcissist
• The Dos and Don’ts of CoParenting with a Narcissist

Featured image by Julie L. Hall.